‘Legacy of Lies’ recalls the lingering horrors of 1980s El Salvador

Robert Nickelsberg

/

Legacy of Lies

Salvadorans examine corpses in the city morgue in La Libertad, El Salvador, Aug. 10, 1984. The victims had been tortured and executed at close range, shot in the face, methods used by right-wing death squads during the civil war.

“Well, you have to take on a different meaning of the word ‘normal,'” he says.

“Vultures actually weren’t the first thing we looked for. It was victim dumping sites that were scattered around the capital, San Salvador, particularly near the slums or periphery of the city.

“In a conflict zone, seeing these levels of violence, and the chaos it causes within a society — you have to be able to figure it out rationally, and put your emotions aside very often.”

“But yes, it accumulates inside you.”

At the same time, many other Legacy of Lies photos are visually beautiful or striking in ways that will remind people of the dignity of ordinary Salvadorans — as well as the causes of the horrible conflict they were trapped in.

One of a religious procession, for example, exudes an almost dreamlike quality — while another, of an elderly coffee plantation worker struggling with an overweight bag of harvested beans, seems to capture the root injustices that led to El Salvador’s guerrilla uprising.

Robert Nickelsberg

/

Legacy of Lies

An altar with a statue of Jesus Christ is carried in a religious procession through the streets in Perquín, Morazán department, El Salvador, October 23, 1983.

“When I initially went to Central America, it was to illustrate U.S. foreign policy,” says Nickelsberg, a Vermont native.

“But first I had to understand the narrative of the Salvadorans — because I found that the concerns of the people at that time were overlooked by U.S. policy and shoved aside.”

El Salvador, in fact, had become one of the Cold War’s many proxy conflicts, and the U.S. got involved there on the side of the abusive oligarchy and military, whose officers and soldiers it helped train and arm.

Not that the leftist guerrillas were saints, either. But Nickelsberg writes, “What we captured graphically contradicted what the Reagan Administration claimed was occurring in El Salvador.” Hence the book’s title.

“U.S. officials would testify that Salvadoran human rights were getting better, but there was no possible way — and I had pictures to prove that.”

Robert Nickelsberg

“It seemed every month, every six months, particularly with the [U.S.] House and Senate hearings on Salvadoran human rights and approving the military aid, State Department officials would testify that things are getting better.”

“And on the ground, there was no possible way that things were getting better — and I had pictures to prove that. We would just shake our heads and say, ‘What — what are they thinking?'”

“The U.S. knew fully that there was no check on the [Salvadoran] death squads and the security forces.”

Courtesy Robert Nickelsberg

Robert Nickelsberg photographing a campesino in El Salvador in 1983.

“They thought they could make democracy trickle down through a Salvadoran elite that in reality could have cared less — that shared none of those values and had no intention of accommodating them.”

Legacy of Lies also contains essays from some of the most respected correspondents covering El Salvador at that time — including Alma Guillermoprieto, who for the Washington Post helped uncover the horrific 1981 El Mozote massacre of a thousand Salvadorans villagers by the infamous Atlacatl army batallion.

“It does come back to haunt people,” Nickelsberg says. “And if they can put those emotions and facts together again, that’s what you get in the strong essays that the book has.”

Another essayist is Salvadoran journalist Carlos Dada, whose family was exiled in Mexico during the civil war. Today, as founder of the digital newspaper El Faro, Dada again finds himself in exile for confronting the dictatorial Bukele, who this year secured a second presidential term in violation of the constitution.

It’s a reminder that Nickelsberg’s book isn’t just a remembrance of El Salvador’s past, but a warning about its present and future, and the U.S.’s role in it.

If you go:
Robert Nickelsberg will present Legacy of Lies: El Salvador 1981-84
WHERE: Florida International University at the Maurice Ferré Institute of the Green School of International and Public Affairs (2nd floor)
WHEN: Tuesday, Oct. 1, at 3 pm
More info here.