Nicaragua's fragile leader and his ruthless crackdown on rivals

Reuters

Daniel Ortega was first elected president of Nicaragua in 1984

Before he was murdered in 1978, journalist Pedro Joaquín Chamorro wrote an open letter to Nicaragua’s dictator, Anastasio Somoza Debayle. In it, he told the reviled military leader how much the people on the streets despised him and that his iron rule resembled “that of a king in children’s stories”.

Three years later, Chamorro was dead, forced off the road and gunned down by Somoza’s henchmen. Today, his daughter, the presidential candidate Cristiana Chamorro, is under house arrest by the government of Daniel Ortega, the man who helped force Somoza from power.

Her detention on money-laundering charges is part of an alarming clampdown on high-profile opponents to President Ortega and his wife, Vice-President Rosario Murillo. In all, five potential candidates for the presidential election in November 2021 have been arrested, as well as numerous journalists and businessmen, most of them under a controversial treason law.

“We’re in a period of absolute irrationality in Nicaragua,” says poet and novelist Gioconda Belli.

On Wednesday, Daniel Ortega reappeared in public for the first time since May. Looking frail, the 75-year-old delivered a typically bombastic speech which lasted for more than an hour and covered everything from North Korea’s nuclear ambitions to the recent spate of arrests.

He insists the actions were justified, and said the detainees would be “punished according to the law” for supposedly carrying out crimes against the state. “Nicaragua is the safest country in the region,” he claimed defiantly.

Not, however, if you are one of the president’s critics.

Gioconda Belli says Vice-President Murillo’s recent speeches have been equally erratic, “a mixture of religion and insults which rail constantly against ‘coup-plotters’ and Satanism. The government’s narratives exhibit extreme levels of paranoia.”

Getty Images

President Ortega and his wife, Vice-President Rosario Murillo, seen here during an event in 2018 in Managua

In part, the presidential couple’s fear and suspicion are rooted in the events of 2018 when protests over pension reforms quickly grew into much larger anti-government demonstrations. The authorities responded with lethal force and more than 300 people were killed, the majority of them anti-Ortega protesters.

“In 2018, they lost the streets,” says Nicaraguan sociologist Oscar René Vargas. “The repression was carried out so that people wouldn’t return to the streets again.”

The treason law and subsequent crackdown are signs the president and his wife view their rule as “fragile”, he argues. They have turned to the “only force they have left – an alliance between the military, the police and [radical pro-Ortega] paramilitaries”.

That is a potent and frightening prospect for any vocal critic or presidential rival. “They’re trying to decapitate the leaders of a social movement and remove any possibility of a new tsunami of social uprising”, Mr René Vargas says bleakly.

Reuters

Police officers stand outside the residence of Cristiana Chamorro, who is under house arrest

Among those arrested is Dora María Téllez, a former commander with the Sandinista rebel group who led a split from Daniel Ortega in 1990 after he lost power following Nicaragua’s violent civil war.

When I last spoke to her, she was in hiding from the Ortega government. A day earlier, her home had been raided by government agents and she could barely hide her disgust at her former ally, even though they had parted ways many years earlier.

Nicaragua has “zero democracy, completely corrupted institutions, a regime which solely remains in place through repression and terror,” she said from an undisclosed location. She now faces the prospect of 15 years in prison.

The treason law states in generic terms that anyone found guilty of acting against “the independence, the sovereignty and self-determination” of Nicaragua could be designated a traitor. A deeply compromised judiciary can easily conflate legitimate criticism of the president with crimes against the state.

Nicaragua timeline

1937 – General Somoza elected president. Rules until his assassination in 1956, succeeded by his son, Luis Somoza Debayle

1967 – Luis Somoza dies and is succeeded by his brother, Anastasio Somoza

1978 – Assassination of opposition leader Pedro Joaquín Chamorro brings together moderates and rebels from the Sandinista National Liberation Front (FSLN) to oust Somoza, who flees in 1979

1984 – Daniel Ortega elected president

1990 – Ortega defeated in an election by Violeta Chamorro

2006 – After losing two elections, Ortega is re-elected after rebranding as Christian socialist

2011 – Ortega allowed to stand for re-election following constitutional changes and wins

2016 – Ortega re-elected again

Oscar René Vargas thinks the equation being made behind the closed doors of the presidential palace in Managua is simple: “Power, or death”. He says that refers to a political death as much as a physical one but believes one ghost from the Cold War in particular stalks Mr Ortega’s thoughts.

“They’re scared of ending up like Nicolae Ceausescu in Romania”, he remarks, referring to the country’s communist dictator who was executed by a firing squad after a national revolt in December 1989. “I think that scenario is present in his mind.”

Gioconda Belli says another experience also haunts Mr Ortega: his election defeat in 1990. Losing the presidency left a profound mark on him and it took him almost two decades to claw back power. Now he appears determined to hold on to it at any cost.

Reuters

Cristiana Chamorro is the daughter of ex-President Violeta Chamorro

“The emperor has no clothes, the emperor is naked,” says Ms Belli. “That’s what Pedro Joaquín said to Somoza and that is what’s been happening to Ortega since 2018. But as they have no capacity for self-reflection over the things they’ve done, they blame the people instead.”